Blog

The Importance of Editing in Art

 

 

“I didn't have time to write a short letter, so I wrote a long one instead.” - Mark Twain

 

There's an important truth in that quote:  the power of focus.  

 

Every great writer will tell you that great writing is great editing.  A first draft is often long, meandering and confusing, but with enough editing, a first draft can become a polished gem conciseness.  But editing isn't important solely for the sake of brevity, but mostly for the sake of clarity.  Because it's extremely difficult and time-consuming to cut needless words, editing is a process that separates the "Joes" from the "Pros".   But if you don't cut those words to make your point crystal clear, the reader will usually wonder, what's your point?

 

A similar dynamic around the power of focus applies to visual art.  

 

For example, I've always admired, but not quite understood, some highly detailed photo-realistic paintings. [1]  If you paint every leaf, every blade of grass, and every wrinkle in the cloth, it's technically amazing, but, like reading a first draft story, I'm often left wondering "what's the point?"  "What's the story here?"  What is this artist trying to say?"   "What was the inspiration?"

 

One goal of great art is to communicate, not just imitate.  

 

I want to know what inspired you about the scene.  When you're painting,  ask yourself the following questions:

 

What's really important about this scene?

What visual elements support the story you're trying to tell?  

 

And then, by careful cutting and editing, make that important story clear to the viewer.

 

If every leaf on the tree is central to the story, then by all means, paint every leaf.  But, for example, if the story is about the temptation of the beautiful, perfect apple hanging from the tree of knowledge, with Eve's hand about to grasp it.... then why not let the leaves fade into the background a bit?  Perhaps paint them with a bit less detail and color, and then punch up the color and detail on the apple itself to entice the viewer's eye to clearly see the story you're actually telling.

 

In fact, I coined a phrase a few years ago that captures this thought:

 

A painter shows me what he painted, but an artist shows me why she painted.

 

 

Sincerely,

 

 

Clint Watson

FASO Founder, Software Craftsman, Art Fanatic

 

 

--------------------

 

Footnotes

 

[1]  I do love great photo-realism.  Great photo-realists understand the power of focus and use it to their advantage, both to enhance the artwork and to increase the focus of the work.

 

Share This Post


Comments

 

Clint:
THANK YOU! Yes, this comment is exactly what I needed. I'm in the middle of painting miniatures for a show and your comment emphasized and defined the need for good editing as a way to highlight the meaning of one's work! Basically, you are often closer to your finish line before you think you are! In my case, since these are miniatures, my rhythm is different; it doesn't take quite as long to complete a study, and I need to be cognizant of that as I paint so as not to overdo. Well done!

Clear, to the point, important, relevant and most important - concise!

I'm sharing with my artistic friends. -- It's a great reminder.

I just took a break from painting hoping to return with a fresh eye and give my feet a rest and read
your email. I'm hoping when I go back to my painting I won't find I'm guilty of over expressing. Enjoyed your article very much and also your verse. Thank you.

What a great reminder! Especially in this hectic-fast paced world people don't have time to look at a bunch of boring,unessential detail.

Thanks for the reminder!

This is a good reminder! It is something I always need to think about.Thanks for the post!

Great phrase. If we do all of the work, there is no reason for a viewer to give more than a glance. Leaving some of the paintings slightly unfocused causes them to really look deeper.

Perfect! Thank you

Great and timely post. Thanks.

As a professional writer and a budding/blooming artist, your words went straight to my heart. When I teach writers, I long ago learned two rules: 1. Get the words down. 2. Fix them. I find this works with the painting just as well. But now I have something even better for the painting - your words about the difference between "what" and "why."

Thanks so much for this.

Major light bulb moment in reading your blog! Your following two statements have made their way in my list of quotes to live by and I thank you for sharing these insights:
-A painter shows me what he painted, but an artist shows me why she painted” and
-One goal of great art is to communicate, not just imitate.”

Oops - sorry about that but my intended quotation marks changed themselves to changed to strange hieroglyphics (acented a and question marks) when I posted my comment.. Now that was definitely an incorrect edit LOL - Goes to show that one must first be a human in order to edit.

Oh no! that last repeat of -changed to - was an human editing error....I think there's a lesson that trying to get through to me, fallible human I am. Perhaps editing also takes humility?

Thank you! With permission, I would like to read this to my 26 art students. I have been trying to say this very thing but you have said it more poignantly - (succinctly and well edited). And it might do them some good hearing it from a knowledgeable person.

Dainn,

Yes, of course you can share it with your students!

Clint


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post