Blog


For the Love of It

An artist wrote me and said, "I do painting for the love, as I just explained to someone this morning, while defending all the money spent versus nothing sold.   I've never approached the easel with $$ in mind."

Unfortunately in our money-driven, ROI-focused society, many people don't get it.  After all, why would this artist continue to "waste" money on her craft if nothing is selling?  It's tragic that she feels forced to defend her decision to spend money on the thing she enjoys most in her life.

I, however, completely "get it."  It's really very simple.  She enjoys "The Maker's High" from painting, which is one of the greatest rushes anyone can have in this life.  There's a reason that "Creativity" is in the very tip, at the "self actualization" level of Maslow's Heirarchy of Needs.  

You see, the artist who wrote me is an amateur artist.  And I mean that as a huge compliment, in the noblest sense of the word.  We seem to have destroyed the true meanings of the words amateur and professional. [1]

The word “amateur” comes from a French word meaning: "lover of".  An amateur is someone who pursues the craft of something like music or art because they love doing it.  A professional does it for money. [2]

I've often seen masterful works by "amateurs" and truly horrible schlock by "professionals."  In fact, I don't think an artist can achieve true mastery without working for the simple love of creating....as amateurs do.  I've occasionally met those who are in it mostly for money and their work is usually.....lacking.

I said above that I completely "get it."   Here's why:  when I was in high school and college, I fell in love with music and playing guitar.  That started my life-long love affair with guitar playing.  

I can see people criticizing me for the amount of time and money I spend on my "amateur" guitar playing.  But it brings me joy.  "Blowing" money on creative endeavors is perfectly valid, and certainly better than "blowing" it on a trip to Vegas or most of the other trivial diversions modern society has designed to take our money.

I'd rather spend four hours playing guitar than four hours wasting my life watching the latest reality TV any day.  And, I often do spend four hours playing.  It always amazes me how fast time disappears when you're in the "zone."  

When you enjoy something creative to the point that you love doing it, and you spend hours and hours immersed in it, you deserve to work with great tools that make your time even more enjoyable...the best tools you can afford.  So, last year I bought a a rather expensive acoustic guitar [3] - it's the same guitar many "professional" players use on stage.

Will I ever make money with my playing?  No, at least not seriously.  Do I care? No.  

I have spent hours with that guitar and it's easily, in terms of enjoyment hours, the best large sum of money I've ever spent.  It's definitely not the last expensive guitar I'll purchase.


People who don't "get" it, think it's a waste of money.  And that's sad for them.

Remember, Sharing Art Enriches Life.

Sincerely,

Clint Watson

FASO Founder, Software Craftsman and Art Fanatic

PS - I feel the same way about creating cool stuff with computer code.  Fortunately for me, that "gig" turned out to have a market, so I guess, technically, I'm a professional "Software Craftsman."   But I assure you I remain an amateur at heart.

**********

[1] We've done the same thing to the word gentleman.  In our society, we use the word "gentleman" to mean a "nice guy."  A gentleman in the historical sense was akin to someone in the noble class...someone who had a title and owned land.   "To a degree, gentleman signified a man with an income derived from property, a legacy or some other source, and was thus independently wealthy and did not need to work." [source]  So, until we screwed up the word, it was possible and, indeed often the case, that a man could be both gentleman and, also, a real ass.

[2]  http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amateur

[3]  I didn't want to publicly give exact figures of what the guitar cost, but to share the order of magnitude, the price had three zeros, not two, at the end.

 

Share This Post


Comments

 

I feel the exact same way. I'm not an artist but I do crochet, knit, and cross stitch.

The yarns are not that expensive - some of them as little as $3.00 each. But some projects take quite a bit of yarn. I made a blanket that, not including my time, cost upwards of $60.00. That's pretty expensive for just a throw blanket.

But I spent hours and hours on that blanket. It was time I spent talking to my family. It was time I spent exercising my creative mind. It was time I wasn't mindlessly watching TV or mindlessly eating a bunch of garbage (it's hard to eat and do yarn stuff - hands are busy and you're afraid to get crumbs on the yarn).

I was happy the whole time. I'm always happy when I crochet. It's a great stress reliever and it's an old skill that is making a real come back.

But the point of this ramble is to say that I can't keep everything I make so I give it away and people think I'm crazy for that. I'm not doing it for profit - I'm doing it because it makes me happy and fills me with peace. That's what really matters and I think if more people did things just for the love of it as you mentioned, there would be a lot more happy people on this planet.

Not everything has a measurable ROI.

Great subject.
So much writing on art tends to measure and judge an artists success in "making" art together with their success(or not), in "marketing" art. I wish all essays about art would start out designating as to whether they are targeting "makers" or "marketers", as many times it is two completely separate audiences. Many, if not most, of the best artists around are either not good at, or not concerned with, marketing. I would guess the same is probably true of musicians...
If you believe you are making good art or music, you are a successful artist, many "amateurs" fail to recognize this. If you are selling art well, you are a successful salesperson (some artists fail to recognize THIS also) ;-)

Hey Clint,

It's nice to hear someone else understands doing it just for the love of it!!! I have been for years and recently got a simple website for my art because all my friends said I needed one to start selling my work instead of giving it away to family and friends. So now I have a website for people to look at my work. But, sculptures are mounted and paintings are framed and hung in my home for me. Thanks for sharing!

Clint, I got my answer, why do I paint, when people look at the passion with which I continue to pour my heart over my canvasses, and wonder whether I am sane, even making me think , sometimes the same..with the general opinion that art does not sell.Thanks for this post , I can now answer, I love it, the fresh oils, the raw canvas and my amateur symbolic art!
http://[email protected]

Thank you, Clint. I will never feel bad about spending more than I make on my art again. It truly is a passion for me to paint, and now I have the freedom to do it without regret at not "selling" enough to support my habit. As habits go, I could have a lot worse ones. :)

yes at the core our involvement with creative pursuits has to be driven by our love for this work - by an inevitability that this is what we must do to feed our souls. "professionalism" becomes a positive enhancement to this core when it provides motivation to seek higher levels of excellence in what we create, how we share that creation. and if money comes - how we re-invest that capital to further our own capacity to create and to build the art markets

Clint it wasnt a Maton guitar (http://maton.com.au/)was it?

No, I'm not affiliated with Maton, I just love well made Aussie things. :-)


Sometimes it is better if we dont make money from something we love. Once money is involved it's amazing how fast it can mess things up!

Thanks so much for the reminder! Lately I have been fighting the way the world thinks about how to cram so much into a minute and never relaxing for the pleasure of down time to be creative. Our culture is paying for such a demand on time. Whenever I get caught up in wondering if the painting on my easel will sell, I have to stop and remember it was never about that.

Eugene - no it wasn't a Maton - it's actually the guitar pictured at the top, a USA brand, Taylor. The Matons look really cool on the website though. Before it's all over, I also want a Martin. I'm also considering a nylon string but I don't know what brands to consider there.

Pamela - no, it's not really about whether it will sell. (although if you're a professional artist you have to keep that in mind). One of the things I LOVE about being an amateur guitarist is there is absolutely no pressure. I just have fun and get better. I see my friends who are semi-pro at music and they're always stressed about it. I don't know if I'd play a real gig even if you paid me (pun intended)

Clint, great post! I see that many professionals, even athletes have an ameture pastime. I think it's healthy, mentally.

Sometimes, I get so wrapped up with wondering what will sell best that I lose my focus and muse. One way that I keep sane is by creating something else besides paintings... something that no one else cares about but me. Lately, I've been exploring painting on fabric - instead of making paintings on canvas, I'm making functional art for myself. I also painted a small table with my own design.

Carrie, I love to knit too - before getting more involved with painting, I spent a lot of time designing and knitting sweaters.

All that said, I need to be careful not to start worrying about selling these other things because that takes away the comfort aspect... I'm creating something that can have mistakes, because it's not for sale.

Winston Churchill wrote a book called, Painting as a Pastime. Even he made time for creative mediation with paint. I guess he was a true amatuer.

Thanks Clint for your thoughts. Would enjoy hearing you play at some point.

Guitar-$0000-Bravo!

Great topic Clint.

You hit the nail on the head: some things we do for ourselves only.

Many creative folks channel their creativity in various disciplines and follow the surest one for the money, but we need to re-charge the battery at the end of the day. Those other endeavors fill that purpose: to give something to yourself to fill the well....and maybe jump start another idea.

I have been playing guitar since I was about 12 and finally purchased a Taylor myself. My music is for me, but I have found a way to bring it into my soundtracks for my documentary films. So I perform, but in a controlled way :-)

And it IS worth spending on your art (professional or amateur) because a professional tool/instrument can help the 'music' flow without the usual effort that comes from playing a poor 'instrument'. Feed your head. Thanks!

Your article hit home, like nothing I've ever seen. I've always been an artist, love painting with a passion, work in wood (decorative carving,relief and many other areas), I'm always expanding my abilities, and try to work more with it, as its what I want to do when I retire. But the clincher is the guitar, I took banjo lessons back in the 70's and have always liked a wide variety of music, but my wife bought me a Gibson Dobro for my birthday one year, this is the first year that I put time aside to take lessons, even though I play around with an amplified electric a lot of the time, I do write my own music or lyrics, and have had them copyrighted, its just like you've said ; you really have to enjoy life for everything its worth, like that old jingle the army used for a long time : Be the best that you can be. Its all so true

thanks for these great comments. congrats on starting up guitar. remember - there is a core of truth at every experiential level. likewise there can be great artistry and a great artistic experience even at the beginner level. a finger placed cleanly on a fret, resulting in a beautifully resonating sound from the string. get it?

Hi Clint,
I to am into amateur guitar playing since I was a teen, many decades ago but still enjoy playing for fun. It's a great break after spending time painting and painting. Which I also do for the love of it.
Other artist friends of mine also play music and for the past three years you'll find us on Saturday night playing at the local coffee shop on "open mic night" and another coffee shop every other Wednesday. It's great fun. No money just fun.

I recently put together a song I wrote and sang and played all the instruments and I recorded it called Peace and Love. And then "just for fun" posted it on you tube. Added a slide show to it. It's there in the Music section under that title with my name.

I think Love of Art and Music well they just go together.

Yeah I started with one cheap guitar then a Fender Strat and all the gear piece by piece then a nice Martin then this and that and then Garage Band apps and .... Well it is much better than sitting and watching TV.

But I still manage to go to two drawing sessions and a painting class during the week and still find time to paint every day and build my own frames for special pieces.



Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post