Blog

You Can't Harvest the Crop Before You Sow the Seeds

You can't harvest the crop before you sow the seeds.

For years, I've been the guy whose been standing mostly alone, in the wilderness, telling artists that, for the most part, SEO efforts are not a good use of artists' marketing time and budget.

I get a lot of flack for this position.  There are many people out there selling courses, doing webinars, and pushing products that teach artists how to do SEO.  Many artists see it as a path to the promised land of "traffic" and sales.  I can see why:  for those of us who did business in a world before Google, the idea is enticing...set everything up "correctly" and watch a steady stream of customers come to your site.  But, unfortunately, for most artists, that path won't work.  And, over the years, we, at FASO, have found other methods of online marketing to be far more effective for artists than SEO.

But the "SEO Myth" continues to be pervasive.  And I've clearly not done a great job at articulating why it doesn't work.  But, once again, Seth Godin has come to my rescue and boiled it down to one sentence:

"Search marketing harvests demand, it doesn't create it"

- Seth Godin [1]

And the vast majority of artists I meet need to create demand for their art, not simply sit back and harvest some existing high traffic search term.  

Common sense:  before people know about your art, they aren't searching for it.

So, please, stop trying to harvest a non-existent crop of traffic, and start sowing the seeds of demand.

Remember, Sharing Art Enriches Life.

Sincerely,

Clint Watson

FASO Founder, Software Craftsman, Art Fanatic

**********

[1] http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2012/10/harvest-demand-or-create-it.html

 

Share This Post


Comments

 

Hi Clint,

I think you are right..... I'm getting this feeling more and more.

Now, I already have a website, and am on DPW. Okay. I also mess around with Facebook a little bit (much to my chagrin) and I guess I'll start a board on Pinterest? BUT, when is enough, enough?? What else is necessary to create this demand? I am as slow as a turtle when it comes to computer work......I know in my heart, I'd be further ahead if I could just spend a lot more time in the studio. As you so correctly put it, if not enough people know about you, then there cannot be a large demand for your work. If I choose not to be in a gallery, but rep my own paintings, then I find I'm on this computer way too much!!! I rely a lot on word of mouth, because I do commission work. But I'd like to do more paintings just for myself and cut way back on commissions. So what else must be done to create this demand, particularly if the SEO isn't doing enough?

Marhsa - that's a topic for another post, however my standard answer would be:

Email Newsletters

I see you sent one on 10/5/2012 and your stats show a huge surge on your site right after that.

Yes, I did see that. I guess that's my point. More computer work.
If only you knew how long it took me to get that done. LOL!!

Clint, I also need to say this, along with what I just sent you. I am
SO GLAD that FASO has good tech help!!! I'd probably still not have
sent that newsletter! Sometimes I know they must sigh when they see my name contacting them about something. But they are a great group, and so patient. LOL!!

Yay Clint! Totally agree. This reminds me of when an artist wanted to rent a building for a gallery because it was in a main state road. She explained that a gazillion aves drive by that building. I asked how many people stop the car and get out tp stroll... In a way, SEO is akin tom those cars driving by, they may see your key words, but they aren't stopping to walk and look in your shop.

Gazillion cars... It almost typed in Cats.... LOL.

"cats" would have worked. As in cool "cats" like the beatniks would say....

Once again I'm reminded about the miles and miles and miles of paint ahead of me!! Happily along the way, I'm going to beautiful places and meeting wonderful people... (And maybe sewing just a few seeds.)

Thank you Clint, for once again sounding the voice of reason about SEO. When I first started blogging I read a lot about how important it was, and I saw a lot of ugly blogpost titles demonstrating that the artist knew how to write for SEO. After a while I thought: so what? Lori's analogy is a good one: traffic in itself means nothing other than that it's passing you by.
If you sell most of your work to random visitors who landed on your site via search engines, then SEO might be a good investment of your time, but I think this is true for very few artists. It certainly isn't true for me.
Perhaps a part of the problem lies in our human temptation to hop on the bandwagon. If 'everyone' says SEO is important, and they are offering tutorials about it, then we must learn it and apply it. But that can turn into a time-consuming distraction with little benefit. To me it makes more sense to promote your work and your sites in places where people go to look for art than to try to lure the occasional random visitor who might just be in the mood to buy one of your works.

Well said. Good distinction. I love Seth - get his post emailed to me every day. I'll work on the doing and the sharing of my art for now.

Clint,
May I ask about the beautiful image at the beginning of the article?
By the way, I totally agree with your point of view on this!
Naomi


Leave a Comment

Remember Your Info
Check this box if you want email updates when people comment on this post